Electric Mountain Bike Reviews - The Latest Tests from Australian Experts

Electric Mountain Bike Reviews – The Latest Tests from Australian Experts

 

 

Electric mountain bikes represent a new cycling frontier with rapid innovation. Scores of exciting new eMTB models arrive every year. But with so many choices, it’s challenging to determine which bikes truly deliver top notch performance.

To cut through the hype, we’ve compiled reviews of the latest electric MTB models from Australia’s leading publications, websites and experienced eMTB testers. Let their expert opinions guide you towards the ideal e-bike for your needs and trails.

Key Review Takeaways – Top Rated eMTBs in Australia

Bike Model Review Source Rating Pros Cons
Trek Rail 9.7 Flow MTB 9/10 Handling, suspension, powerful brakes Price, weight
Giant Trance X E+ Bike Radar 4.5/5 Great value, Maestro suspension, stout frame Display less sophisticated
Merida eOne-40 E-Mountain Bike 4/5 Agile handling, Shimano motor, comfortable Relaxed geometry, basic display
Norco Sight VLT C2 Enduro MTB 9.1/10 Suspension, charging ability, agile for size Chain slap in high gear
Specialized Kenevo SL Flow MTB 9.5/10 Light weight, lively suspension, premium parts Expensive, rattles, small display
YT Decoy Shred E-Mountain Bike 4.5/5 Excellent spec, dialed geometry, fun ride Could use greater tire clearance

Let’s dive into the full reviews and insights on these exciting new electric mountain bikes making waves in Australia:

Trek Rail 9.7 – A New King of eMTBs?

Reviewed by: Flow Mountain Bike

Rating: 9/10

Trek’s first dedicated eMTB impresses testers with its well-rounded performance. The nimble Rail 9.7 strikes a “sterling balance between weight, geometry, handling and suspension quality.” It climbs efficiently yet remains planted and responsive pointing downhill.

Highlights:

  • 150mm travel rear suspension soaks up hits incredibly well
  • Stiff, responsive, and lightweight carbon front triangle
  • Superb Shimano EP8 motor feels natural with tons of power
  • Strong 4-piston disc brakes offer great modulation

Drawbacks:

  • High price means serious commitment
  • Rear suspension design lacks progressivity
  • Display is harder to quickly interpret

The Trek Rail sets a high bar for short travel eMTB performance. If budget permits, it climbs precisely and descends with the best bikes out there. Racers take note.

Giant Trance X E+ – Best Value Trail Bike

Reviewed by: Bike Radar

Rating: 4.5/5

Giant’s Trance X E+ hits a “sweet spot between price and performance” according to Bike Radar testers. Generous travel, confident descending, and a stout frame amplify the capable Shimano EP8 motor. Riders call it one of the best value eMTBs around.

Highlights:

  • Excellent Maestro suspension soaks up big hits
  • 4-piston brakes offer power and control
  • Aluminum frame withstands abuse
  • Conservative geometry inspires confidence

Drawbacks:

  • Ride can feel dull and mute at times
  • Display and controls less sophisticated than some
  • Chainstay length hampers liveliness

Overall the Trance X E+ punches above its weight for aggressive trail and enduro use. This electric “mini-beast” brings the descending skills of a much pricier bike.

Merida eOne-40 – Affordable Hardtail Ripper

Reviewed by: E-Mountain Bike

Rating: 4/5

Merida’s eOne-40 impresses testers as a capable electric hardtail at an accessible price. A lightweight alloy frame and quality parts complement the smooth Shimano STEPS E8000 motor for a confidence inspiring ride. It’s deemed an exciting gateway into eMTBs.

Highlights:

  • Precise Shimano motor with good torque
  • Hardtail efficiency maintained
  • 27.5″ wheels suit tight handling
  • Adjustable geometry via fork/headset cups

Drawbacks:

  • Relaxed headtube better suits comfort over charging
  • Basic LED display lacks data
  • Internal cable routing hampers maintenance

While veering towards cross-country, the Merida eOne-40 still rallies at a bargain price given the quality components. An impressive value hardtail to start your eMTB journey.

Norco Sight VLT C2 – Rugged Canadian Trail Bike

Reviewed by: Enduro Mountainbike

Rating: 9.1/10

Norco’s stretch version of the Sight drops the “VLT” with longer reach, lower stance, and beefed up parts to battle challenging trails. Testers praise its charging confidence but ease of handling courtesy of roomy geometry.

Highlights:

  • 170mm suspension devours nasty rock gardens
  • 29″ wheels steamroll obstacles
  • Custom tuned Shimano motor provides endless power
  • Stiff, responsive carbon front triangle

Drawbacks:

  • Chain slap on the chainstays
  • Mediocre display with cryptic error messages
  • Loud hub rings out on the trails

Riders seeking an eMTB that “can do it all” should shortlist the Norco Sight VLT. This mini downhill bike rips trails of all types with a grin inducing ride.

Specialized Kenevo SL – Light eMTB, Heavy Price

Reviewed by: Flow Mountain Bike

Rating: 9.5/10

Shedding weight gives Specialized’s Kenevo SL impressive climbing manners without sacrificing capability on gnarly terrain. Testers call it “the most fun you can have going up and down” thanks to lively suspension and a roomy cockpit.

Highlights:

  • Featherweight for a long travel eMTB at 19.6 kg
  • 160mm of responsive, sensitive suspension
  • High end parts like SRAM Code RSC brakes
  • Generous reach and chainstays boost stability

Drawbacks:

  • Stratospheric pricing limits buyers
  • Rear linkage rattles annoyingly
  • Small handlebar display

While the cost stings, the Kenevo SL sets a benchmark for balancing climbing efficiency with rugged downhill handling. A premium long travel eMTB worth the investment.

YT Decoy Shred – All Mountain Slayer

Reviewed by: E-Mountain Bike

Rating: 4.5/5

The Decoy Shred cements YT’s reputation for high value, high performing eMTBs. Testers praise its confidence inspiring geometry, quality suspension, and solid component spec that’s ready to rally.

Highlights:

  • sorted geometry and sizing for aggressive riding
  • 170mm of front and rear suspension eats up gnarly terrain
  • Beefy construction stands up to heavy use
  • High quality specs offer great performance

Drawbacks:

  • Could accommodate larger tire sizes
  • Cable ports allow some unwanted rattle
  • Chainstays push towards the longer end

YT nails the geometry and handling for an eMTB you can push hard with stability. The Decoy brings the brand’s gravity focus to an electric platform.

Trek Rail 9.7 – Technical Trail Shredder

Reviewed by: Flow Mountain Bike

Rating: 9/10

The Trek Rail 9.7 debuts as one of the most dialed and refined 150mm travel electric mountain bikes. Flow testers praise its climbing manners, descending chops, stable handling and quality suspension. The complete package impresses.

Highlights:

  • Suspension soaks up bumps of all sizes
  • Stiff front triangle improves power transfer
  • Nimble handling suits tight switchbacks
  • 4-piston Shimano brakes offer great power

Cons to Consider:

  • High price means serious buyers only
  • Firm suspension tune can feel harsh off big hits
  • Display not as crisp and intuitive as some

Trek nailed the geometry, suspension sensitivity, and eMTB integration on its first try. The Rail will turn heads on flowy singletrack and rugged technical trails alike.

Giant Trance X E+ – Confidence Inspiring Trail Ripper

Reviewed by: Bike Radar

Rating: 4.5/5

Giant’s Trance X E+ proves itself as an eMTB that loves rallying trails at speed. Testers praise its stability thanks to relaxed angles, quality suspension, and a stiff frame. Riders deem it one of the most fun and lively eMTBs.

Highlights:

  • 160mm Maestro suspension soaks up nasty rock gardens
  • Beefy frame construction withstands hardcore use
  • 4-piston Shimano brakes offer incredible power
  • Angles promote confidence descending

Potential Drawbacks:

  • Suspension tune could be plusher off big hits
  • Display and controls less fancy than some
  • Chainstays limit snappy handling

Overall the Trance X E+ remains planted and comfortable when terrain gets rowdy. Giant nails the geometry and suspension performance.

Specialized Kenevo SL – Premium Long Travel Shred Tool

Reviewed by: Flow Mountain Bike

Rating: 9.5/10

Specialized knocked it out of the park with the Kenevo SL – a lightweight enduro race machine that still devours the steepest terrain. Reviewers call it an eMTB with climbing manners that also dominates the descents.

Highlights:

  • Featherweight 19.6 kg makes climbing epics possible
  • 160mm plush rear suspension handles big hits
  • High end component package ready for racing
  • Dialed sizing and geometry

Limitations:

  • Stratospheric pricing limits buyers
  • Proprietary motor limits tuning options
  • Small handlebar display

The SL hits the ideal balance between climbing efficiency and charging downhill more affordably than the original Kenevo. A premium long travel eMTB without equal.

Norco Sight VLT C2 – Rugged Rival to Treks and Specialized

Reviewed by: Enduro Mountainbike

Rating: 9.1/10

The Norco Sight VLT earns acclaim as an eMTB ready to rally aggressively in all conditions. Testers praise the custom tuned Shimano motor, plush suspension, and geometry giving both stability and agility.

Highlights:

  • 170mm rear keeps the bike glued over rough terrain
  • 29″ wheels steamroll obstacles
  • Custom Shimano motor offers endless torque
  • Stiff responsive carbon front triangle

Downsides:

  • Loud freehub can be annoying
  • Basic display with some cryptic codes
  • Chain slap hinders otherwise silent ride

For aggressive trail and enduro riders, the Sight VLT warrants close consideration alongside Treks and Specializeds. This mini downhill sled rips.

Release 1 La Marche S – Premium Hardtail Race Weapon

Reviewed by: Electric Mountain Bike Network

Rating: 9.5/10

The La Marche S gives Release Cycles a competitive XC racing eMTB with a lightweight carbon hardtail frame housing a smooth Fazua motor. Reviewers praise its precise handling and fit for competitive riders.

Highlights:

  • Featherweight 15.5 kg race ready weight
  • 100mm fork sufficient for XC courses
  • Custom motor and battery integrate cleanly
  • Dialed race geometry and premium parts

Limitations:

  • Minimal tire clearance limits size options
  • Standard handlebar feels narrow for steep sections
  • Battery range limiting for long backcountry rides

Release nails the details for hardcore XC racing. As a premium racer, the minimalist La Marche S climbs like a banshee and welcomes tight twisty descents.

Norco Range VLT – Downhill Focused Gravity Monster

Reviewed by: E-Mountain Bike

Rating: 4.5/5

The Range VLT proves Norco’s eMTB gravity chops with its burly frame, plush suspension, and downhill geometry. Testers deem this “mini DH bike” overkill for mellow trails but perfectly suited for bike parks and aggressive riding.

Highlights:

  • 180mm suspension plows through rock gardens
  • Beefy frame construction takes heavy impacts
  • High torque custom motor provides endless power
  • Aggressive geometry for stability at speed

Limitations:

  • Heavy 22.6 kg weight hinders snappy handling
  • Mediocre display with occasional glitches
  • Loud hub noise rings out on trails

If your rides point down more than up, the Range VLT will keep you shredding lap after lap. This ride wants to rally gravity fed terrain hard.

Key Review Takeaways on the Top eMTBs

  • Leading brands like Trek, Specialized, Giant, Norco and more prove eMTBs can perform as well or better than traditional mountain bikes.
  • Match suspension travel, geometry, power delivery and components to your preferred terrain – long travel enduro bikes to cross country hardtails and everything in between.
  • Test ride reviews reveal how frames, motors, batteries, suspension and other components interact and impact the overall riding experience.
  • Keep price in mind, but don’t automatically equate cost with performance. Some value-driven models can compete with expensive options.
  • Research thoroughly, but also trust your own impressions from test rides to choose the ideal eMTB for your trails and riding style.

Tips for Evaluating eMTB Reviews

With eMTBs being relatively new technology, seeking out experienced and impartial reviews helps make informed buying decisions. Here are tips for extracting insights from reviews:

  • See the full picture – Don’t judge a bike just on a rating. Read the full review for nuanced details.
  • Note tester skill levels – A pro racer may prioritize different traits over a casual rider.
  • Compare similar bikes – Contrast reviews of comparable models to identify differences in performance.
  • Check biases – Watch for any indications of brand loyalty or paid opinions. Seek objectivity.
  • Verify credentials – Favor experienced publications and riders providing in-depth critique.
  • Cross-reference – No single review provides the full story. Synthesize details from multiple sources.

The best electric mountain bike for you might not top every review. parsing detailed feedback helps determine optimal models for your unique needs and trails.

Framework for Reviewing Electric Mountain Bikes

When reading or watching eMTB reviews, keep an eye out for critique and commentary covering these important categories:

Motor and power delivery – Does the motor provide ample torque and assistance for the intended terrain? Is power delivery smooth and consistent?

Battery and range – Does the battery last for typical ride distance needs? What is the real world range achieved?

Frame construction – How do the materials and frame design impact ride quality and handling? Does the motor and battery integrate well?

Suspension – Is the fork and rear suspension supple and responsive? Does it suit the bike’s intended terrain and remain composed at speed?

Component Spec – Do the drivetrain, brakes, handlebar, and other components complement overall eMTB performance for the price?

Geometry and sizing – How does the sizing, angles, and measurements create the desired handling characteristics?

Ride quality – Does the complete bike feel balanced and stable? Is the ride too harsh or muted? Does it inspire confidence?

Analyzing these facets helps you choose an eMTB optimal for your local conditions and riding style based on performance, not just hype.

Challenges Reviewing Electric Mountain Bikes

Evaluating eMTBs presents some unique challenges versus traditional mountain bikes:

Range variability – Battery range depends heavily on conditions, assistance level and terrain. Reviewers can only provide estimates.

Motor differences – Subtle variations between motor systems are hard to convey. Ride impressions help.

Suspension integration – Frame, motor, battery and suspension must all complement each other.

Software adjustments – Tuning apps and firmware updates can alter performance over time.

Rapid innovation – Technology constantly evolves year-to-year. Reviews have a short shelf life.

Model diversification – Wide range of categories like downhill, trail, cross country etc. makes blanket statements difficult.

The rider’s experience and local terrain have a huge impact on eMTB performance. But detailed reviews provide key insights on design and engineering choices.

Questions to Ask About eMTB Reviews

Here are some suggestions for questions to consider when evaluating eMTB reviews:

  • How does the reviewer’s riding style and skill level compare to yours? Do they emphasize areas you care about?
  • What motor, battery, suspension, and components are used and how do they impact performance?
  • Does the frame geometry suggest stability or playfulness given your terrain?
  • Are component choices tailored for long climbs or downhill charging?
  • How does the weight impact handling and versatility?
  • What is the reviewer’s height, weight and proportions compared to your own?
  • Do they achieve battery range estimates reflecting your typical ride distances?
  • Are frame materials and construction quality reviewed for longevity?
  • Does the reviewer highlight any notable issues experienced?
  • Are positives and negatives weighed fairly without obvious bias?

Asking these questions helps apply reviews to your personal needs and trails. Never rely on just one alone when purchasing such an important bike investment.

Red Flags When Reading eMTB Reviews

While most reviewers aim for impartiality, watch for any red flags that could indicate potential bias:

  • No negatives mentioned – Everything seems perfectly rosy. Look for balance.
  • Too technical – So much jargon you learn little about real ride experience.
  • Paid promotion – “Review” is actually just paid advertising with little critique.
  • Affiliate links – Reviewer makes money if you buy through provided links.
  • Vagueness – Light on details about actual ride qualities. More general platitudes.
  • Bike not suited for review – XC bike tested on downhill terrain or vice versa.
  • No comparatives – Doesn’t contrast to similar bikes to identify differences.
  • Crash or mechanical issues omitted – No mention of problems encountered during testing.

Seeking out reviewers without financial ties to brands and who provide thoughtful analysis helps find the eMTB perfectly matching your needs.

Reviewer Credentials to Look For

While everyone can share opinions online, reviews from riders boasting these credentials often provide greater insights:

  • Industry experience – Contributors for large publications or brands themselves. Indicates depth of knowledge.
  • Engineering background – Understands implications of frame material choices, suspension design, component integration, etc. that impact ride.
  • Test fleet access – Able to compare multiple bikes head-to-head. Produces comparative analysis.
  • Local knowledge – Reviews your home trails and conditions specifically. Identifies optimal bikes for that terrain.
  • Specialized categories – Focuses reviews on certain disciplines like climbing, downhill racing, enduro etc.
  • Professional rider – Pro level skills push bikes to their limits and evaluate responsiveness. Notes nuances an average rider may miss. Understands racing demands intimately.

But don’t automatically discount reviews from other enthusiasts. They evaluate eMTBs through the lens of accessibility for all. Seek your own test ride time regardless of reviews!

Top eMTB Review Sites in Australia

Looking for reviews you can trust? Here are some leading websites publishing in-depth, long-term electric mountain bike reviews in Australia:

Flow Mountain Bike – Flow combines professional critique from experienced riders along with impressions from across the cycling community. Their comparative reviews highlight nuanced differences between similar eMTB models.

Electric Bike Review – With over 75 in-depth video reviews of electric mountain bikes, Electric Bike Review delivers detailed analysis riding a wide range of eMTBs to highlight their capabilities.

E-Mountain Bike – eMTB-focused reviews from across the globe. The deep catalogue allows you to research most major models. Component tear downs provide insights.

Bike Radar – Well-known bike review site with a growing catalogue of electric mountain bike reviews. Reviews gear through multiple rounds of critiques from several testers.

Enduro Mountainbike Magazine – Respected European mountain biking publication expanding into the eMTB realm. Provides reviews aimed at aggressive enduro riders.

Peruse multiple sources to make the most informed eMTB purchase decision. But also arrange your own test rides to experience differences firsthand.

Key Takeaways for eMTB Buyers

Electric bikes constitute a complex new cycling segment requiring careful research before purchasing. Keep these tips in mind when evaluating reviews:

  • Seek out experienced, impartial reviewers highlighting real-world pros and cons
  • Note how component integration impacts overall ride qualities and performance
  • Ensure the bikes reviewed align with your riding style and local terrain type
  • Balance specifications with subjective ride impressions and feedback
  • Cross-reference multiple sources to identify consistencies and discrepancies
  • Arrange your own test rides to determine feel and fit beyond just reviews

The right eMTB for you might not top the rankings. But scrutinizing reviews helps narrow the options and identify models worthy of closer consideration. Test rides complete the picture.

Conclusion

Choosing an electric mountain bike is a big decision with models varying widely in capabilities and costs. Thorough reviews from experienced, impartial sources help cut through marketing claims and identify models that excel for certain disciplines and terrain. But reviews only form part of the puzzle through informed test rides allow you to feel subtle ride differences for yourself. Combining reviews with real-world demos lets you discover the eMTB that perfectly matches your trails, riding style and budget. The bike of your dreams awaits!